Outline
Introduction
In the realm of global health, effective coordination and efficient implementation of interventions are paramount for achieving impactful outcomes. Consider a scenario where a ministry of health in a low-income country is grappling with the challenge of reducing maternal mortality rates. Over the years, multiple international and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have initiated various maternal health interventions, ranging from training programs for healthcare providers to community awareness campaigns. While these efforts were well-intentioned, the lack of coordination and harmonisation among the implementing entities resulted in duplicated activities, overlapping resources, and fragmented approaches. As a consequence, the impact of these interventions was limited, and the desired reduction in maternal mortality rates remained elusive.
This situation not only strained the limited resources of the ministry but also led to confusion among healthcare providers and communities, as they were bombarded with similar messages and programs without a clear, unified strategy. The challenge of repeated interventions and fragmented efforts highlights the urgent need for a coordinated approach.
To overcome this obstacle and maximise the impact of interventions, ministries can tap into the transformative power of Technical Working Groups (TWGs). These strategic platforms for coordination and collaboration hold the potential to optimise resources, foster knowledge sharing, and ensure the effectiveness of interventions, thereby paving the way towards more robust and more resilient health systems.
The Evolution of Technical Working Groups
TWGs have a rich history rooted in the need for coordination and collaboration among stakeholders working towards common health goals. Their origins can be traced back to the 20th century, with the establishment of interagency working groups in response to specific health challenges.
Early Adoption and Disease-Specific Focus
In the 1980s and 1990s, disease-specific TWGs emerged as a response to global health challenges, notably the HIV/AIDS pandemic. The establishment of TWGs, such as those led by the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), played a critical role in coordinating the global HIV response. These TWGs brought together experts, researchers, policymakers, and practitioners from various sectors to develop comprehensive prevention, treatment, care, and support strategies. Through collaborative efforts, TWGs developed guidelines, protocols, and best practices, ensuring the effective implementation of interventions worldwide. For instance, the development of antiretroviral therapy protocols, prevention of mother-to-child transmission strategies, and community-based care models were all outcomes of TWG-driven initiatives.
Expansion to Cross-Cutting Themes
As the understanding of health systems grew, TWGs expanded their focus to address cross-cutting themes in global health. In the early 2000s, TWGs prioritised broader health system components beyond disease-specific interventions. This shift recognised the need for integrated approaches to strengthen health systems and achieve sustainable impact. TWGs started addressing critical areas such as health workforce development, health financing, health information systems, and governance. For example, TWGs focused on developing strategies to address health workforce shortages, ensuring equitable distribution of healthcare professionals, improving health financing mechanisms, strengthening health information systems for better data collection and analysis, and enhancing governance frameworks for efficient health service delivery. These cross-cutting themes allowed TWGs to address systemic challenges and contribute to the overall strengthening of health systems.
Intersectoral Collaboration
In recent years, there has been a growing recognition of the importance of intersectoral collaboration in global health. TWGs have increasingly engaged stakeholders from diverse sectors beyond health, including education, agriculture, the environment, and social welfare. This multidisciplinary approach recognises that various social determinants influence health outcomes. By involving different sectors, TWGs aim to address the underlying causes of health issues and promote comprehensive interventions. For instance, TWGs have facilitated collaborations between the health and education sectors to improve school health programs and strengthen preservice training of health providers, between health and agriculture sectors to address nutrition and food security, and between health and environmental sectors to tackle vector-borne diseases. This intersectoral collaboration allows for a more holistic approach to health, acknowledging that health is influenced by factors beyond the healthcare system alone.
Regional and National Adoption
TWGs have gained significant traction at regional and national levels, with many countries and regions recognising their value as a vital component of their health systems. African countries have demonstrated notable progress in adopting and implementing TWGs to address priority health issues and strengthen health systems. For example, in the fight against malaria, TWGs have been instrumental in coordinating national malaria control programs, promoting best practices for vector control, ensuring access to diagnostic tools and effective treatment, and strengthening surveillance systems. Similarly, TWGs have played a crucial role in immunisation programs, bringing together stakeholders to develop vaccination strategies, monitor coverage rates, and address challenges in vaccine delivery. Additionally, TWGs have been involved in improving maternal and child health outcomes, focusing on areas such as antenatal care, skilled birth attendance, and postnatal care, with initiatives aimed at reducing maternal and child mortality rates.
Advantages of TWGs for Partner Institutions
TWGs offer significant advantages to partner institutions, enabling them to leverage the collective expertise and resources of diverse stakeholders:
A platform for Knowledge Sharing: TWGs serve as platforms for knowledge exchange among stakeholders, fostering collaboration and learning. Partner institutions can share their experiences, best practices, and lessons learned from implementing interventions. This knowledge sharing enables participants to gain insights into successful strategies, innovative approaches, and challenges encountered, which can inform the design and implementation of future interventions. It promotes evidence-based decision-making, enhances program effectiveness, and avoids the repetition of ineffective strategies.
Utilising Monitoring and Evaluation Data: TWGs provide partner institutions access to valuable monitoring and evaluation data. Through data sharing and analysis, partner institutions can comprehensively understand intervention outcomes, impact, and areas requiring improvement. This data-driven approach enables evidence-based decision-making, as stakeholders can draw upon the insights gained from monitoring and evaluation to adjust strategies, allocate resources more effectively, and refine interventions to maximise impact. Using such data saves time, money, and human resources by avoiding the repetition of strategies that have proven ineffective and directing efforts towards more promising approaches.
Long-term Evaluation of Impact: TWGs offer an advantage in evaluating the long-term impact of interventions even after implementing organisations have moved on. By continuing to monitor and assess the outcomes and sustainability of interventions, partner institutions can gain insights into the lasting effects on the target population and health systems. This information allows for evidence-based decision-making and contributes to the development of more effective and sustainable interventions in the future. It enables partner institutions to evaluate the success and challenges faced in the long run, learn from their experiences, and incorporate those lessons into future programs and policies.
Fostering Effective Coordination and Alignment
Developing clear and comprehensive terms of reference (TOR) and guidelines for TWGs is crucial for ensuring their effective functioning. These documents provide a roadmap for the TWG's activities, outlining its purpose, objectives, roles, responsibilities, and operating procedures. By establishing TOR and guidelines, ministries of health and partner institutions can create a structured framework that guides the TWG's operations and ensures clarity and alignment among stakeholders.
The development of TOR helps define the scope of the TWG's work, specifying the focus areas and expected outcomes. It clarifies the roles and responsibilities of each member, ensuring that everyone understands their contributions and commitments. Guidelines provide specific instructions on meeting schedules, reporting mechanisms, decision-making processes, and resource allocation. This standardisation streamlines the functioning of the TWG, minimises conflicts, and promotes accountability.
Having well-defined TOR and guidelines also helps maintain the focus of the TWG on its objectives and prevents mission drift. It ensures that discussions and activities remain aligned with the agreed-upon goals, avoiding wasting time and resources on unrelated matters. Moreover, TOR and guidelines provide a reference point for evaluating the performance and effectiveness of the TWG, allowing for periodic reviews and adjustments to enhance its impact.
To maximise the impact of TWGs, several strategies can be employed:
Enhance multilateral and bilateral collaborations to foster synergy and resource sharing.
To facilitate collective learning and innovation and promote effective communication and information exchange among TWGs.
Ensure inclusive and equitable representation within TWGs, giving voice to marginalised communities and vulnerable populations.
Strengthen monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to track progress, identify gaps, and enable evidence-based decision-making.
Encourage regular knowledge-sharing platforms and policy dialogues to disseminate best practices and lessons learned from TWG activities.
Conclusion
The power of policymakers and implementers lies in their ability to leverage Technical Working Groups as catalysts for coordinated interventions and strengthened health systems. By harnessing the collective expertise, resources, and coordination mechanisms provided by TWGs, ministries can achieve a more significant impact, avoid repeated efforts, and optimise the use of limited resources. Through successful TWGs, African countries have made significant strides in addressing diseases and health system challenges.
As we work towards stronger health systems globally, we must recognise the value of TWGs and invest in their establishment and functioning. By embracing coordination and collaboration through TWGs, ministries of health can pave the way for a more effective, efficient, and equitable approach to improving population health.
Dr. Achieng' Aling' is a global health professional with a strong focus on health system strengthening and sexual reproductive health. Passionate about advancing global health, she is committed to knowledge sharing to drive positive change and promote healthy lives.
Comments